← Junior Engineer

Past Questions — 2025

Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Which steel section is best suited for columns in steel structures?

A) I-section or H-section
B) T-section
C) Circular rods
D) L-section
Columns are structural members primarily subjected to axial compressive loads. The primary failure mode for columns is buckling. To resist buckling, a section needs a high Moment of Inertia (I) and a large Radius of Gyration (r) about both principal axes. 1. **I-sections and H-sections (Wide Flange):** These sections distribute material far from the centroidal axes, providing a high moment of inertia. H-sections, in particular, are designed to have nearly equal moments of inertia about both the X and Y axes, making them highly efficient for columns to prevent buckling in any direction. 2. **T-sections:** These are asymmetrical and have a lower radius of gyration compared to H-sections for the same area of steel, making them less efficient for primary axial loads. 3. **Circular rods:** While good for pure compression, they are inefficient in terms of the strength-to-weight ratio compared to H-sections for large-scale structural columns. 4. **L-sections (Angles):** These are typically used for bracing or small supports. They have a very low radius of gyration and are highly susceptible to buckling when used as primary columns.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Which type of joint is NOT commonly used in steel structures?

A) Welded joint
B) Mortar joint
C) Bolted joint
D) Riveted joint
In steel structure design, joints are used to connect structural members to transfer loads. 1. Welded joints (Option a) are common, involving the fusion of metals using heat. 2. Bolted joints (Option c) are the most prevalent modern method for connecting steel sections due to ease of installation and versatility. 3. Riveted joints (Option d) were the primary method of connection in early steel structures (like the Eiffel Tower) and are still found in older bridges and buildings, though largely replaced by bolting. 4. Mortar joints (Option b) are used exclusively in masonry construction (brickwork or stonework) to bind units together. Mortar is a mixture of cement, sand, and water, which has no structural application for joining steel-to-steel members. Therefore, it is NOT used in steel structures.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Which code governs general steel design in India?

A) IS 456
B) IS 3370
C) IS 800
D) IS 875 Part 2
The correct code for the general design of steel structures in India is IS 800. The current version (IS 800:2007) specifies the requirements for the design of steel structures using the Limit State Method. Analysis of other options: - IS 456: This is the code of practice for Plain and Reinforced Concrete (RCC). - IS 3370: This code governs the design and construction of liquid retaining structures (like water tanks). - IS 875 Part 2: This is part of the code for design loads for buildings, specifically dealing with Wind Loads.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Salvage value means:

A) Sale value before use
B) Expected resale value after useful life
C) Net profit
D) Depreciation amount
In the context of Estimation, Costing, and Engineering Economics, 'Salvage Value' (also known as scrap value or residual value) is defined as the estimated value of an asset at the end of its useful economic life. It represents the amount that can be recovered by selling the asset or its components for scrap after it is no longer functional or efficient for its original purpose. Analysis of options: - Option (a) 'Sale value before use' refers to the initial cost or purchase price, not salvage value. - Option (b) 'Expected resale value after useful life' is the precise definition of salvage value. - Option (c) 'Net profit' is the financial gain after all expenses are deducted from total revenue, which is unrelated to the valuation of a single asset at the end of its life. - Option (d) 'Depreciation amount' is the total loss in value of an asset over time. While salvage value is used to calculate depreciation (e.g., Straight Line Method: Depreciation = (Cost - Salvage Value) / Life), it is not the depreciation amount itself.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

What is the primary function of a granular sub-base (GSB)?

A) Drain rainwater
B) Hold bitumen
C) Provide structural support and drainage
D) Reflect sunlight
In flexible pavement design, the Granular Sub-Base (GSB) is the layer situated between the subgrade (natural soil) and the base course. Its primary functions are twofold: 1. Structural Support: It distributes the traffic load over a wider area of the subgrade, reducing the pressure exerted on the natural soil to prevent deformation. 2. Drainage: GSB is designed with specific grading to act as a drainage layer, allowing water that has seeped through the upper layers to drain away laterally, thereby preventing the saturation of the subgrade and protecting the pavement from frost heave or moisture-induced failure. Why other options are incorrect: - Option (a): While GSB does drain water, 'drain rainwater' is too narrow; its primary role is to manage internal drainage and provide structural stability. - Option (b): Bitumen is held by the surface course and base course (in the case of bituminous bases); GSB is typically an unbound granular material and does not function to 'hold' bitumen. - Option (d): Reflecting sunlight is a property of the surface wearing course (albedo), not a subsurface layer like GSB.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Cost index is used to:

A) Calculate final bill
B) Adjust historical cost estimates for inflation
C) Determine profit margin
D) Add contingency
A Cost Index (also known as a Price Index) is a numerical indicator used in civil engineering and construction estimation to reflect the change in the cost of materials, labor, and equipment over a period of time. 1. Why Option (b) is correct: When an engineer has a cost estimate from a previous project (historical cost) and needs to estimate the cost for a similar project today, they apply the cost index to account for inflation and market fluctuations. The formula is generally: Current Cost = (Historical Cost) × (Current Index / Base Index). 2. Why Option (a) is incorrect: The final bill is calculated based on actual measurements of work done (Quantity Surveying) and agreed-upon contract rates, not by applying a general cost index. 3. Why Option (c) is incorrect: Profit margin is a percentage added to the total cost of construction to ensure the contractor earns a return on investment; it is independent of the cost index. 4. Why Option (d) is incorrect: Contingencies are sums of money set aside to cover unforeseen expenses or emergencies during construction, typically calculated as a percentage (e.g., 3-5%) of the total estimate, not via a cost index.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Chain surveying is suitable for:

A) Small, fairly level areas
B) Forests
C) Hilly terrains
D) Long-distance roads
Chain surveying is the simplest method of surveying where only linear measurements are taken in the field. 1. Why Option (a) is correct: Chain surveying relies on the principle of triangulation. It is most effective and accurate in small, flat, or level areas where there are few obstructions, allowing the chain to be stretched straight between two points. 2. Why Option (b) is incorrect: Forests contain dense vegetation and obstacles that prevent the stretching of a chain in a straight line, making chain surveying impractical. 3. Why Option (c) is incorrect: In hilly terrains, measuring horizontal distances with a chain is extremely difficult and inaccurate due to the slope. Compass or Plane Table surveying is preferred in such terrains. 4. Why Option (d) is incorrect: For long-distance roads, the cumulative error in chaining becomes significant, and the process becomes too time-consuming. Theodolite surveying or GPS/Total Station surveying is used for linear projects like roads.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

A work can commence only after obtaining:

A) Drawing set submitted by contractor
B) Administrative and technical sanction
C) Final bill approval by competent authority
D) Contractor’s bank details
In government engineering projects and public works, a project must undergo a formal approval process before any physical work can commence on site. 1. **Administrative Sanction (AS):** This is the formal approval by the competent administrative authority (e.g., the government department) stating that the project is necessary and that the estimated expenditure is acceptable. It signifies the 'approval of the project' in principle. 2. **Technical Sanction (TS):** This is the approval given by the competent technical authority (e.g., Chief Engineer or Superintending Engineer) after reviewing the detailed estimates, designs, and drawings. It ensures that the project is technically sound and the cost estimation is accurate. Without both AS and TS, funds cannot be allocated, and the tender process cannot be legally finalized to start the work. Why other options are incorrect: - Option (a): Drawings are usually provided by the department to the contractor, or submitted by the contractor for approval *after* the work is awarded, but they are not the primary legal authorization to start the project. - Option (c): The final bill is processed at the *end* of the project, not the beginning. - Option (d): Bank details are required for payment processing, but they are a clerical requirement, not a regulatory prerequisite for the commencement of the work itself.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Which condition would require applying the mid-section formula instead of the center line method?

A) Simple rectangular buildings
B) Curved or irregular trenches
C) Flat RCC roof
D) Wall painting work
In estimation and costing, the 'Center Line Method' is used for calculating quantities of work (like excavation or masonry) by calculating the total length of the center line of the walls. However, this method becomes inaccurate or overly complex when dealing with curved walls, irregular shapes, or varying widths, as the center line length does not consistently represent the average volume. The 'Mid-Section Method' (or Mid-Sectional Area method) involves calculating the cross-sectional area at the mid-point of a section and multiplying it by the length. This is specifically used for irregular shapes, curved trenches, or earthwork where the cross-section varies along the length. Analysis of other options: - a. Simple rectangular buildings: These are ideally suited for the Center Line Method due to straight lines and right angles. - c. Flat RCC roof: This is typically calculated using the area method (Length x Width x Thickness). - d. Wall painting work: This is a surface area calculation (Length x Height), not a volumetric calculation requiring center line or mid-section methods.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Septic tanks are designed primarily for:

A) Drinking water storage
B) Primary treatment of sewage
C) Stormwater collection
D) Rainwater harvesting
A septic tank is a underground wastewater collection tank where sewage is stored. It functions as a primary treatment unit through two main processes: sedimentation and anaerobic digestion. 1. Sedimentation: Heavier organic and inorganic solids settle to the bottom to form a layer of sludge. 2. Anaerobic Digestion: Bacteria break down the organic matter in the absence of oxygen. The resulting liquid (effluent) is then typically discharged into a soak pit or drainage field for further secondary treatment. Why other options are incorrect: - Option (a) Drinking water storage: Septic tanks handle waste (sewage), which is contaminated and hazardous; they are never used for potable water. - Option (c) Stormwater collection: Stormwater is typically handled by separate storm drains or detention ponds to prevent the septic system from overflowing or flooding. - Option (d) Rainwater harvesting: This involves collecting clean rain for reuse, whereas a septic tank is designed for the disposal and treatment of waste.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Tachometric readings in hilly terrain vary frequently. What technique improves consistency?

A) Use plane table
B) Shift benchmark
C) Take multiple readings and average them
D) Ignore steep slopes
In tachometry, readings are obtained by observing stadia hairs on a leveling staff. In hilly terrain, several factors can cause inconsistency in readings, including unstable ground for the staff, atmospheric refraction, and the difficulty of holding the staff perfectly vertical on steep slopes. To mitigate random errors and improve the precision and consistency of the data, the standard surveying practice is to take multiple observations (readings) from the same station and calculate their arithmetic mean (average). This reduces the impact of accidental errors. Why other options are incorrect: - (a) Plane table surveying is a graphical method and is not a technique used to improve the accuracy of tachometric (optical) readings. - (b) Shifting the benchmark changes the reference point for elevation but does not improve the consistency of the readings taken between the instrument and the staff. - (d) Ignoring steep slopes is technically impossible and professionally incorrect, as the purpose of surveying hilly terrain is specifically to map those slopes accurately.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

A contractor quoted 20% below estimated cost. What should be done before awarding the work?

A) Reject the bid
B) Ask for rate justification and verify feasibility
C) Accept directly
D) Skip work order
In civil engineering procurement and contract management, a bid that is significantly lower than the estimated cost (often referred to as an 'unbalanced bid' or 'abnormally low bid') is a red flag. While the lowest bidder is generally preferred, a quote 20% below the estimate suggests a risk of 'under-quoting'. This can lead to several problems: the contractor may use inferior materials, abandon the project midway due to financial losses, or attempt to recover costs through excessive claims and variations. Therefore, the standard administrative procedure is to ask the contractor for a 'Rate Analysis' or 'Rate Justification' to prove that they can execute the work qualitatively and sustainably at that price. - Option (a) is incorrect because a bid cannot be rejected solely on price without giving the contractor a chance to justify their efficiency or cost-saving methods. - Option (c) is incorrect because accepting an abnormally low bid without verification risks project failure. - Option (d) is incorrect as skipping the work order is not a corrective action for a low bid.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

The term ‘hardness’ in water refers to presence of:

A) Suspended solids
B) Calcium and magnesium salts
C) Iron
D) Algae
Hardness in water is a chemical characteristic defined as the capacity of water to precipitate soap. It is primarily caused by the presence of multivalent metallic cations. The most prevalent ions responsible for hardness in natural water supplies are Calcium (Ca²⁺) and Magnesium (Mg²⁺) ions, usually occurring as carbonates, bicarbonates, sulfates, or chlorides. - Option (a) Suspended solids refer to turbidity and physical impurities, not chemical hardness. - Option (c) Iron can contribute to hardness and staining, but it is not the primary constituent that defines 'hardness' in standard environmental engineering contexts. - Option (d) Algae are biological contaminants that affect taste, odor, and dissolved oxygen, but do not cause hardness.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Sinking fund is invested in:

A) Labor accounts
B) Insurance premiums
C) Safe interest-bearing instruments
D) Cement procurement
A Sinking Fund is a fund formed by setting aside a certain amount of money periodically (usually annually) over a specific period to accumulate a required sum by the end of the period. In civil engineering and public works, this is typically used to replace a structure or pay off a debt at the end of its useful life. To ensure the fund grows and the principal is protected, the money is invested in 'safe interest-bearing instruments' (such as government bonds or fixed deposits). This allows the fund to earn compound interest, reducing the actual annual amount that needs to be contributed from the revenue. Why other options are incorrect: - a. Labor accounts: These are operational expenses for paying workers, not investment vehicles. - b. Insurance premiums: These are costs paid for risk mitigation, not a method of accumulating a capital fund for replacement. - d. Cement procurement: This is a material cost for construction, not a financial investment strategy.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Which book is maintained to record all sanctioned works?

A) Muster roll
B) Register of works
C) Cash book
D) MB
In government engineering departments (such as PWD), various registers are maintained for accountability and auditing. 1. **Register of Works (Correct):** This is the primary record where all sanctioned works are entered. It contains details such as the name of the work, administrative approval date, technical sanction date, estimated cost, and the current status of the project. It serves as the master list of all authorized projects. 2. **Muster Roll (Incorrect):** This is used to record the attendance of daily-wage laborers and to calculate their wages for payment. 3. **Cash Book (Incorrect):** This is a financial record used to track all monetary transactions (receipts and payments) of the office on a daily basis. 4. **MB (Measurement Book) (Incorrect):** The MB is the basic record of all measurements of work actually executed. It is used as the basis for preparing bills, but it does not record the 'sanction' of the work itself; it records the 'execution' of the work.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

The MB (Measurement Book) is used for:

A) Estimating work only of executed work
B) Recording actual measurements of executed work
C) Billing laborers of executed work
D) Writing tenders of executed work
The Measurement Book (MB) is the most important legal document in civil engineering projects. It is used to record the actual dimensions and quantities of work performed on-site by a contractor or laborer. These recorded measurements serve as the primary basis for calculating payments (billing) and auditing the project. Why other options are incorrect: - Option (a): Estimating is done before the work begins (Preliminary Estimate) or during planning, whereas the MB is used after the work is executed. - Option (c): While the MB provides the data used to calculate payments, the actual 'billing' process happens in a Bill of Quantities or a Payment Voucher, not within the MB itself. - Option (d): Tenders are documents issued to invite bids for a project; they are prepared based on estimates, not recorded in the MB.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

In analysis of rates, contractor’s profit is usually considered as:

A) 2%
B) 25%
C) 10 to 15%
D) 5%
In the analysis of rates for civil engineering works, the total cost of an item is calculated by adding the cost of materials, labor, and plant/machinery. To this prime cost, additional percentages are added to cover overheads and profit. 1. **Overheads**: These include office rent, staff salaries, electricity, and other administrative expenses. These typically range from 5% to 10%. 2. **Contractor's Profit**: This is the net gain the contractor expects for executing the work and taking the associated risks. In standard practice and according to most Public Works Department (PWD) norms and textbooks on Estimation and Costing, the contractor's profit is generally considered to be between 10% and 15%. Comparing the options: - Option (a) 2% and (d) 5% are too low to cover the risks and business costs of a construction firm. - Option (b) 25% is excessively high and would make the bid uncompetitive in a government tender process. - Option (c) 10 to 15% aligns with the industry standard for rate analysis.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Which process is used to remove suspended solids from water?

A) Disinfection
B) Sedimentation
C) Aeration
D) Chlorination
Step-by-step reasoning: 1. **Analysis of the Goal**: The question asks for the process used to remove 'suspended solids' (particles that are larger than dissolved molecules and remain suspended in the water column) from water. 2. **Evaluating Option (b) Sedimentation**: Sedimentation is a physical water treatment process that uses gravity to remove suspended solids. When water is kept still in a tank (sedimentation basin), heavier particles settle to the bottom over time, forming a sludge layer. This is the primary method for removing bulk suspended solids. 3. **Evaluating Option (a) Disinfection**: Disinfection is the process of killing or inactivating pathogenic microorganisms (bacteria, viruses) using chemical or physical agents. It does not remove physical solids. 4. **Evaluating Option (c) Aeration**: Aeration is the process of bringing water and air into close contact to remove dissolved gases (like CO2 or H2S) or to oxidize dissolved metals (like Iron and Manganese) so they can later be precipitated. It is not used for the primary removal of suspended solids. 5. **Evaluating Option (d) Chlorination**: Chlorination is a specific form of disinfection using chlorine. Like option (a), its purpose is to eliminate biological contaminants, not to remove physical suspended solids. Conclusion: Sedimentation is the only process listed specifically designed to remove suspended solids via gravitational settling.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

The value of CBR is mainly used to design:

A) Rigid pavement
B) Flexible pavement
C) Bridges
D) Shoulders
The California Bearing Ratio (CBR) is a penetration test used to evaluate the mechanical strength of road subgrades and base course materials. 1. **Why Flexible Pavement:** Flexible pavements (like asphalt roads) distribute loads through a layered system where the strength of the underlying soil (subgrade) is critical. The CBR value is the primary parameter used in the design of flexible pavements (e.g., using the IRC or US Army Corps of Engineers methods) to determine the required thickness of the pavement layers to prevent shear failure of the subgrade. 2. **Why not Rigid Pavement:** Rigid pavements (concrete roads) rely on the flexural strength of the concrete slab to distribute loads over a wide area. While the modulus of subgrade reaction (k-value) is used for rigid pavements, the CBR is not the primary design parameter. 3. **Why not Bridges or Shoulders:** Bridges are designed based on structural engineering principles (beams, piers, foundations) and geotechnical bearing capacity, not CBR. Shoulders are secondary components and their design is typically derived from the main pavement design rather than being the primary application of the CBR test.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Which structure needs cost estimation of both excavation and lining?

A) Overhead tank
B) Boundary wall
C) Tube well
D) Steel truss
In civil engineering estimation, different structures require different types of quantity take-offs. 1. **Tube Well**: A tube well involves drilling or digging a deep vertical hole into the ground (Excavation/Boring). To prevent the walls of the borehole from collapsing and to filter water, a casing pipe or a lining of concrete/steel is installed inside the hole. Therefore, both the volume of excavation (boring) and the cost of lining (casing) must be estimated. 2. **Overhead Tank**: While it requires excavation for the foundation, the main structure is an elevated tank. The term 'lining' is not a primary characteristic of the entire structure's estimation in the same way it is for a well. 3. **Boundary Wall**: This requires excavation for the foundation trenches and masonry work, but it does not involve 'lining' (which refers to a continuous internal layer/casing of a void). 4. **Steel Truss**: This is a superstructure element. While its supports (columns/pedestals) require excavation, the truss itself does not involve excavation or lining.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Alum is used in water treatment as a:

A) Disinfectant
B) Filter medium
C) Coagulant
D) Softener
Step-by-step reasoning: 1. **What is Alum?**: Alum (Aluminum Sulfate, Al2(SO4)3) is a chemical compound widely used in water treatment plants. 2. **Mechanism of Action**: In water, alum dissociates to release trivalent aluminum ions (Al3+). These positively charged ions neutralize the negative electrical charges on the surface of colloidal particles (such as clay, silt, and organic matter) that cause turbidity in water. 3. **Coagulation Process**: Once the charges are neutralized, the particles no longer repel each other and begin to clump together to form larger, heavier particles called 'flocs'. This process is known as coagulation. 4. **Evaluating Options**: - **a. Disinfectant**: Disinfectants (like Chlorine or Ozone) are used to kill pathogens. Alum does not kill bacteria. - **b. Filter medium**: Filter media (like sand or anthracite) are physical barriers used to strain particles. Alum is a chemical additive, not a medium. - **c. Coagulant**: This is the correct term for a substance that causes particles to clump together for easier removal. - **d. Softener**: Softeners (like lime or ion-exchange resins) are used to remove hardness (Ca2+ and Mg2+ ions). While alum can affect water chemistry, its primary purpose in water treatment is turbidity removal, not softening.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

A road in hilly terrain frequently erodes during rains. Which immediate corrective measure is most effective?

A) Increase Road width and road thickness
B) Provide proper surface drainage and toe wall
C) Add gravel on top of the surface road
D) Install signboards at a prominent location
In hilly terrain, the primary cause of road erosion during rains is the uncontrolled flow of surface runoff and the instability of the road embankment. 1. **Surface Drainage:** Water flowing over the road surface or down the hillside can wash away the pavement and subgrade if not channeled. Proper surface drainage (such as side drains, chutes, and cross-drainage works) ensures that water is collected and diverted safely away from the road structure, preventing scouring and erosion. 2. **Toe Wall:** A toe wall is a retaining structure built at the base (toe) of the road embankment. It prevents the slope from sliding and protects the base of the road from being eroded by water flowing down the hill or from the side drains, thereby stabilizing the entire road section. Why other options are incorrect: - **Option a:** Increasing width and thickness does not address the cause of erosion (water flow) and may actually increase the load on an unstable slope, potentially leading to landslides. - **Option c:** Adding gravel is a temporary 'patch' and not a corrective engineering measure; without drainage, the gravel will simply be washed away during the next rain. - **Option d:** Signboards are safety measures for traffic management, not engineering solutions for structural erosion.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

The purpose of providing camber in road pavement is to:

A) Reduce noise
B) Control traffic flow
C) Increase surface friction
D) Facilitate drainage
Camber (also known as cross-slope) is the convexity provided to the surface of the road pavement. Its primary engineering purpose is to ensure that rainwater drains off the pavement surface quickly toward the side drains. This prevents the accumulation of water (ponding) on the road, which would otherwise lead to hydroplaning for vehicles and cause rapid deterioration of the pavement structure through seepage and potholes. Analysis of other options: - a. Reduce noise: Noise reduction is achieved through the use of specific materials (like open-graded asphalt) or sound barriers, not by the slope of the road. - b. Control traffic flow: Traffic flow is controlled by signals, signs, lane markings, and speed limits. - c. Increase surface friction: Surface friction (skid resistance) is provided by the texture of the wearing course (aggregate interlock), not by the camber.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

What is the purpose of earnest money deposit (EMD)?

A) To start work early by contractor
B) To ensure seriousness of bid submitted by contractor
C) To pay laborers by contractor
D) To fund procurement by contractor
Earnest Money Deposit (EMD) is a security deposit submitted by a contractor along with their tender/bid. Its primary purpose is to ensure that the bidder is genuine and serious about the project. If the contractor wins the bid but refuses to sign the contract or fails to provide the required performance security, the EMD is forfeited by the department. This prevents frivolous bidding and protects the employer from the delays associated with non-responsive bidders. Analysis of other options: - Option (a) is incorrect because EMD is a deposit for the bidding phase, not a mobilization advance to start work. - Option (c) is incorrect because labor payments are handled through the contractor's own funds or through running account (RA) bills paid by the department after work is executed. - Option (d) is incorrect because procurement is funded by the contractor's working capital or mobilization advances, not by a security deposit held by the client.
Junior Engineer • 2025 • Paper-IV (Technical Subject)

Which is a disadvantage of steel tanks over RCC tanks?

A) Easy fabrication
B) Prone to corrosion
C) High ductility
D) Light weight
To determine the disadvantage of steel tanks compared to Reinforced Cement Concrete (RCC) tanks, we evaluate the properties of both materials: 1. **Corrosion (Option b):** Steel is highly susceptible to oxidation and corrosion, especially when in contact with water or exposed to atmospheric moisture. This requires expensive protective coatings, linings, or cathodic protection to ensure durability. In contrast, RCC is naturally more resistant to corrosion (provided the concrete cover is adequate), making 'prone to corrosion' a significant disadvantage of steel tanks. 2. **Fabrication (Option a):** Steel tanks are generally easier and faster to fabricate and assemble (often using welding or bolting) compared to the time-consuming process of formwork, reinforcement tying, and curing required for RCC tanks. This is an advantage, not a disadvantage. 3. **Ductility (Option c):** Steel has high ductility, which allows it to undergo significant deformation before failure and better withstand seismic loads. This is generally considered a structural advantage. 4. **Weight (Option d):** Steel tanks have a much higher strength-to-weight ratio than RCC tanks, making them lighter for the same capacity. This reduces the load on the foundation and simplifies transportation. This is an advantage. Therefore, the only negative attribute listed is the susceptibility to corrosion.
Page 1
← Prev Next →